Carney, J.N., Horak, J.M., Pharaoh, T.C., Gibbons, W., Wilson, D., Barclay, W.J., Bevins, R.E., Cope, J.C.W. & Ford, T.D. 2000. Precambrian Rocks of England and Wales. Geological Conservation Review Series, No. 20, JNCC, Peterborough, ISBN 1 86107 4875. The original source material for these web pages has been made available by the JNCC under the Open Government Licence 3.0. Full details in the JNCC Open Data Policy
Chapter 1 Introduction to the Precambrian rocks of England and Wales
T.C. Pharaoh and J.N. Carne
Overview
The Precambrian rocks of England and Wales are associated with some of Britain's most beautiful countryside (see for example, the front cover): Charnwood Forest, the Malvern Hills, Shropshire and the Welsh Borders, the fringes of Snowdonia and the rugged coastline of Anglesey and Llŷn (the Lleyn Peninsula). This scenic diversity is largely a consequence of the hardness of these rocks and is a legacy of the tectonic, metamorphic and alteration processes they have suffered in their long history, rendering them resistant to the forces of erosion.
The Precambrian outcrops are sparsely distributed and generally occupy relatively small areas of southern Britain
An outstanding feature seen in three of the outcrop areas is the occurrence of enigmatic fossil impressions, which are the local representatives of the world-famous Ediacaran fauna. New fossil discoveries are still being made, and will contribute to the on-going debate (Chapter 8) about exactly what types of organisms flourished in the late Precambrian seas.
'Precambrian' is a broadly used term for rocks that pre-date the Phanerozoic Eon (i.e. Cambrian or younger). It encompasses such a vast span of time, extending back to at least 4000 Ma (four thousand million years ago), that it has been subdivided into two Eons, the Archaean which in the UK only occurs in NW Scotland (to be described in the GCR companion volume Lewisian, Torridonian and Moine Rocks of Scotland) — and the younger Proterozoic Eon. The Precambrian rocks described in the present volume belong to the latter, specifically to its youngest part, which has been given the chronological term 'Neoproterozoic'. Their precise range within the Neoproterozoic, and the age of the chronological boundary with Cambrian Period, will be discussed further below.
It should be noted that three of the GCR sites, featured in Chapter 9, contain rocks that, on the balance of current evidence, may not be Precambrian. Two of these sites, in Charnwood Forest, contain trace fossils that indicate an early Cambrian age for the uppermost part of the succession (Bland, 1994). At the third site, Ingleton Group strata of the Chapel-le-Dale Inlier at Thornton in northern England are now believed to be contemporary, although not necessarily direct correlatives, with the Ordovician-age (Arenig–Llanvirn) Skiddaw Group of the Lake District (Cooper et al., 1993). There is also an ongoing controversy regarding the age of the Monian Supergroup of Anglesey, which is discussed in the introduction to Chapter 7 of this volume.
The distribution of most of these outcrops is at least in part determined by fault systems that have episodically uplifted the Precambrian 'basement' from beneath successive coverings of younger (Phanerozoic) sedimentary strata. For example, the largest area of outcrop, in Anglesey and the adjacent Llŷn region of North Wales (Chapter 7), is controlled by the Menai Strait Fault System. A further extensive outcrop, forming the network of GCR sites in the Shropshire to Llangynog region (Chapter 5), lies within the Welsh Borderland Fault System. Both of these fault systems have had a long and complex history that probably began in latest Neoproterozoic time at about 600 Ma. The Precambrian inliers of Charnwood Forest (Chapter 2) and Nuneaton (Chapter 3) are simi larly controlled by major crustal lineaments on the eastern side of the wedge-shaped Midlands Microcraton, shown in
A scientific framework for the Precambrian rocks
The Precambrian basement of southern Britain is most conveniently grouped into a number of large crustal entities, called 'terranes'. Each terrane represents a microcosm of geological evolution
Explanation of the terrane concept
The geological 'terrane' is not to be confused with 'terrain' (a physiographical feature). The concept sprang from studies of the Western Cordilleran orogenic margin of North America in the late 1970s, which recognized that a large proportion of the crust in this region was 'sus pect' (exotic) with respect to the adjacent cratonic continental area (Coney et al., 1980). It was soon determined that these exotic crustal slices had in fact originated as 'suspect terranes' in regions at some considerable remove, frequently by thousands of kilometres, from the orogenic belt where they had eventually ended up. It followed that the present orogenic belt was itself an accretionary collage, composed of numerous terranes derived from around the circum-Pacific region and now 'welded' together along major faults. These concepts were soon applied to other, older orogenic belts, e.g. the Appalachian belt of North America (Williams and Hatcher, 1982), the Caledonides and Variscides of Europe (e.g. Ziegler, 1982) — and subsequently to the Precambrian of southern Britain (e.g. Gibbons, 1987; Gibbons and Horik, 1996). Support for the new hypothesis came not only from structural and lithological studies, but also from studies of faunal biodiversity and palaeomagnetism.
The principles of terrane analysis require a rigorous evaluation of the stratigraphical and structural history of each geological domain to examine its linkages to the surrounding ones (Howell, 1995). If the tectonostratigraphical history of the domain is different to that of its neighbours, it is considered suspect with respect to the latter. Thus it is possible that some part of the region may be composed of allochthonous (= far travelled) crustal fragments that subsequently came into contact (sutured together or 'docked') with each other. While stratigraphical and structural criteria are very important in terrane definition, other useful criteria include: magmatic and metamorphic history; palaeomagnetic data, giving absolute values for palaeolatitudinal and rotational displacement when calibrated by high quality radiometric ages; and biostratigraphical data, indicating episodes of faunal provinciality (continental isolation).
The importance of geochemistry in Precambrian terrane characterization
The geochemical signature of magmatic suites, determined from plots of major and trace element and isotopic data, may be extremely useful in terrane correlation and their implications are much discussed in the introductions to the various GCR site networks and/or volume chapters.
Bimodal suites comprise magmas of contrasting, usually basic and acid, compositions. The basic magma, typically iron-rich or tholeiitic basalt, represents a mantle melt that may have suffered a comparatively minor amount of modification as it has passed through the crust. By contrast the acid magma (typically a rhyolite) may have been generated by interaction of the basic magma with the crust itself, e.g. by partial melting.
Calc-alkaline suites exhibit a range of composition, e.g. basalt-andesite-dacite-rhyodacite, but are unimodal and dominated by rocks of intermediate composition, in particular andesite and dacite (or their plutonic equivalents).
Geochemical patterns commonly utilize the immobile major and trace elements that are the least susceptible to change as a result of subsequent alteration and/or metamorphism. Their content in lava is normalized, for example with respect to mid-ocean-ridge basalt (MORB), and then compared to the abundances in samples from known tectonic environments (Pearce, 1982). The pattern that results may be used to identify the nature of the lithospheric mantle source region, for example whether it has volcanic arc or within plate components, and thus provide a useful indication of the tectonic environment of origin of a particular magmatic suite. This in turn can be used as a constraint to deduce the environments of lava and pyroclastic eruption, or of accumulation in the case of thick volcano-sedimentary sequences.
Determination of absolute ages of the Precambrian rocks
Considerations of terrane evolution are crucially dependent upon accurate determinations of age. This is difficult because Precambrian rocks do not possess the highly diverse and rapidly evolving fossil assemblages characteristic of many Phanerozoic sequences. Their age, when determined, must therefore be an absolute age based upon radiometric dating using the decay schemes of the various radiogenic isotopes contained within the rocks or their mineral components. The absolute age is then referenced to recognized and well-calibrated geological timescales based upon the most precise radiometric data for stratigraphically controlled rock units around the world. For example, the Phanerozoic timescale used here is that published by Gradstein and Ogg (1996). The Precambrian rocks of southern Britain yield isotopic data indicating that they were formed at various times between about 700 and 550 Ma, as shown in the chronologically based correlation chart of
The most reliable radiometric techniques for determining the absolute age of Precambrian rocks is the analysis of the U-Pb isotope system in minerals, and this has yielded analytical precisions as good as 1 Ma for age of crystallization of late Precambrian magmatic rocks in southern Britain (Tucker and Pharaoh, 1991). In addition, the U-Pb isotopic 'concordia' system is inherently robust, allowing complications such as the incorporation of more ancient inherited grains, or the effects of complex thermal, hydrothermal and other alteration histories to be recognized and evaluated by modelling. The ages of crystallization of igneous rocks from many of the rock suites (labelled U or M in
A generalized chronological sequence for the Precambrian rocks
Application of these radiometric-dating tech niques to the Precambrian rocks of England and Wales south and east of the Menai Strait Fault System has led to recognition of the following chronological sequence of events:
- c. 1598 Ma Formation of inherited zircons in Malverns Complex.
- c. 1100 Ma Nd isotope model ages of the Malverns Complex plutonic rocks.
- 700–640 Ma Crystallization of plutonic suites (Stanner–Hanter, Malverns, Johnston Complex) at moderate crustal depths followed by pervasive metamorphism and shear deformation.
- 620–585 Ma Eruption of early arc volcanic and related plutonic suites (Pebidian Supergroup, Sarn Complex, Arfon Group, Charnian Supergroup, volcanics in Orton and Glinton boreholes).
- 570–560 Ma Eruption of late marginal basin-type volcanic suites (Uriconian Group, Warren House Formation).
- 560–?540 Ma Deposition of thick sedimentary sequences (Longmyndian Supergroup, upper part of Arfon Group) in rapidly subsiding pull-apart basins followed by their inversion (uplift and erosion) during late stage Avalonian orogenic events.
- c. 535 Ma Deposition of the Cambrian overstep sequence commences.
By contrast, the Precambrian rocks of Anglesey and northern Llŷn, to the north and west of the Menai Strait Fault System, exhibit the following history
- 1800–1200 Ma Nd isotope model ages of protolith to some of the Central Anglesey gneisses.
- Unknown age. Polyphase deformation-metamorphism of gneisses.
- 615 Ma Emplacement of Coedana Granite into country-rock hornfelses.
- 600 Ma? Formation of oceanic protolith to blueschists.
- 600-?535 Ma Deposition of Monian Supergroup in a fore-arc or arc-trench basin, and development of subduction zone.
- 560–550 Ma Unknown age. Ductile shearing during accretion of Monian terranes followed by terrane dispersion and juxtaposition to Avalonian terranes of England and Wales. Blueschists tectonically emplaced along Menai Strait Fault System.
- c. 490 Ma Deposition of Arenig overstep sequence.
A summary of the Precambrian terranes of southern Britain
The value of terrane analysis is that it provides a highly appropriate conceptual framework for the late Precambrian rocks of England and Wales, which between 700 and about 545 Ma occupied an active plate boundary along the margin of a large continent in the Southern Hemisphere (
The Palaeozoic history of Avalonia is too complex to detail here, but some of the more significant plate movements are shown in
In southern Britain the Precambrian rocks of the Avalon Composite Terrane can be divided into two main groups of terranes
British Avalonian terranes
These terranes each exhibit lithological similarity to the Avalonian sequences of the type area in Newfoundland. The Avalonian belt was sited at high southern latitudes along the Gondwanan plate margin in Neoproterozoic times (Keppie et al., 1998), but it was subsequently fragmented, as shown in
The Fenland Terrane, defined here for the first time, comprises the Precambrian basement of the concealed Caledonides of eastern England (Pharaoh et al., 1987a). This basement is unexposed, proven only by boreholes, and therefore not represented by any GCR sites. A Precambrian age is proven or suspected for felsic tuffs penetrated by three boreholes in eastern England. Ignimbritic ash-flow tuffs of felsic composition (Dearnley, 1966) were encountered by the Glinton and Orton Boreholes
The Charnwood Terrane, defined by Pharaoh et al. (1987b), includes a large network of sites within Charnwood Forest (Chapter 2) and near Nuneaton (Chapter 3). In Charnwood Forest the Charnian Supergroup comprises at least 3.5 km of volcaniclastic rocks deposited in moderately deep water adjacent to a calc-alkaline volcanic arc. Geochemical data suggest that this arc was founded on immature continental crust (Pharaoh et al., 1987b), rather different from that underlying the Fenland Terrane. Numerous bodies of diorite, commonly granophyric textured (North and South Charnwood Diorites and equivalent rocks at Nuneaton), represent the late generation of relatively more evolved, high-K calc-alkaline magmas (Pharaoh et al., 1987b), at about 603 Ma (fucker and Pharaoh, 1991). They intrude most of the bedded sequence, including horizons with Ediacaran fossils.
The Kempsey and Withycombe Farm Boreholes
The Wrekin Terrane was first defined by Pharaoh et al. (1987b). The oldest rocks constitute the bimodal (gabbro–granophyre) Stanner–Hanter Intrusive Complex and the calc-alkaline Malverns Complex of the Malvern Hills GCR site. These plutonic rocks were emplaced at about 702 and 680 Ma respectively (Patchett et al., 1980; Thorpe et al., 1984; Tucker and Pharaoh, 1991), and in the case of the Malverns Complex at least, were recrystallized in the greenschist to low amphibolite metamorphic facies soon after this (Strachan et al., 1996). This plutonic suite probably extends well to the west of the Malverns, perhaps to the Pontesford Lineament of the Welsh Borderland Fault System (Woodcock, 1984a), where the Primrose Hill and Rushton metamorphic suites are thought to be of similar age (Thorpe et al., 1984). The latter are metasedimentary rocks and they, together with the plutonic suites, form a basement to the younger volcano-sedimentary successions of the terrane.
The younger cover sequence commenced with the bimodal-style magmatism of the Uriconian Group, mainly described from the Shropshire GCR sites (Chapter 5), the geochemistry of which indicates eruption within a largely subaerial marginal basin that developed at 566–560 Ma (Tucker and Pharaoh, 1991). The U-Pb zircon date for emplacement of the subvolcanic Ercall Granophyre, at 560 Ma, is presently the most precise constraint for the minimum age of Precambrian magmatism in southern Britain. Another bimodal volcanic suite, so far undated, bearing lithological and geochemical resemblance to the Uriconian Group, is the Coomb Volcanic Formation (Cope and Bevins, 1993; Bevins et al., 1995) of Llangynog in South Wales
The Warren House Formation lavas of the Broad Down (Malvern Hills) GCR site, which are in faulted contact with the Malverns Complex, are of identical age to the Uriconian lavas. Their chemistry, however, is appropriate to an oceanic marginal-basin tectonic setting (Pharaoh et al., 1987b), suggesting that crustal extension may have proceeded further in this part of the Wrekin Terrane.
The Cymru Terrane (literally the 'Wales Terrane'; cymru is pronounced: 'coomray'), defined here for the first time, comprises the Precambrian basement of the deep, early Palaeozoic Welsh Basin, exposed around the northern and southern rims of the latter. In North Wales it includes the Penrhyn Nefyn GCR site showing the Sarn Complex (chapters 6 and 7), of diorites, gabbros and granites forming a calc-alkaline plutonic series emplaced at about 615 Ma (Horák, 1993; Horák et al., 1996). A further component of the Sarn Complex, consisting of garnetiferous rocks (Parwyd Gneisses) is seen at the south-west tip of Llŷn at the Braich y Pwll to Parwyd GCR site.
The Arfon Group (Chapter 6) represents voluminous calc-alkaline felsic magmatism (Padarn Tuff Formation of Reedman et at, 1984) likewise emplaced at about 614 Ma (Tucker and Pharaoh, 1991). Both the Sarn Complex and Arfon Group lie to the south of the Menai Strait Fault System and are in presumed faulted contact with the Monian terranes of Anglesey (Chapter 7). Small, isolated exposures of tuffaceous rocks (Bwlch Gwyn Tuff and Baron Hill Formation) which are lithologically comparable to parts of the Arfon Group succession (Reedman et at, 1984), nevertheless occur within the Berw Shear Zone on Anglesey. According to Gibbons and Horák (1996) these represent fragments of the Cymru Terrane tectonically incorporated within the Monian Terranes and cannot be used to provide an overstep linkage of the type inferred by Tucker and Pharaoh (1991).
The > 2 km thick Pebidian Supergroup, described at the St David's GCR site (Chapter 6), is dominated by volcaniclastic rocks of calc-alkaline composition and was intruded by the St David's Granophyre at about 587 Ma (Patchett and Jocelyn, 1979). Calc-alkaline arc volcanism thus persisted in the Cymru Terrane after 600 Ma. The Monian Terranes of Anglesey and northern Llŷn exhibit no linkage whatever to the Cymru Terrane until Arenig time, and are therefore regarded as suspect to the latter (Gibbons, 1987). The Fenland Terrane (see above) exhibits calc-alkaline volcanism of comparable age and composition to that of the Cymru Terrane but with the limited sampling of the basement in the former provided by boreholes, any correlation of these terranes must remain tentative.
Monian Composite Terrane
This series of terranes, amalgamated into the network of GCR sites described in Chapter 7, represents by far the largest exposure of Precambrian rock in southern Britain. It has at least three distinct components informally referred to by Gibbons and Horák (1990) as 'terranes 1, 2 and 3'
Monian Supergroup ('Terrane 1'). This terrane
The supergroup probably represents the fill of a latest Proterozoic trench-forearc basin
Coedana Terrane ('Terrane 2'). This terrane in central Anglesey comprises various types of gneisses and a large body of intrusive granite, together with mylonitic rocks derived from these protoliths. Although the metamorphic age of these gneisses remains unknown, the emplacement of the Coedana Granite has been dated at about 613 Ma (Tucker and Pharaoh, 1991). An inherited zircon component has an age of about 1440 Ma, which falls within the range of Sm-Nd depleted mantle model ages of 1000–1800 Ma derived from the gneisses themselves (Horák, 1993). Ductile shear zones in the south-east (Central Anglesey Shear Zone) and a steep belt of cataclasite in the north-west (Llyn Traffwll Fault Zone) separate this terrane from its neighbours. Rather similar gneissose and plutonic rocks, with a comparable isotopic history, are present in the Rosslare Complex of south-east Ireland (Horák, 1993).
Aethwy Terrane ('Terrane 3'). The blueschists, exposed within a narrow linear belt in south-east Anglesey, represent the most famous component of the Monian composite Terrane (Chapter 7) and are one of the oldest (possibly the oldest) and best-preserved occurrences of such rocks in the world. They are intensely foliated rocks isolated from all other tectonostratigraphical units by ductile shear zones; the Berw Shear Zone in the north-west and the Bryn Meurig Shear Zone (Gibbons and Horák, 1990; fig.3) in the south-east. The typical mineral assemblage of these rocks is sodic amphibole (glaucophane) together with epidote + haematite + quartz. The blueschists are of prime importance to plate tectonic reconstructions in southern Britain. They are interpreted as the product of early low pressure subsea floor metamorphism at about 590–580 Ma, followed by high pressure/low temperature subduction-related metamorphism at 560–550 Ma (Dallmeyer and Gibbons, 1987).
Precambrian tectonic settings and the terrane accretion model
Various plate-tectonic models e.g. Dewey, (1969), Baker (1971), Wood (1974), Barber and Max (1979), have been applied to the Precambrian rocks of southern Britain, emphasizing such tectonically diagnostic features as:
- Blueschists: subduction metamorphism
- Mélange: trench fill
- Pyroclastic rocks: arc volcanism
These models inferred subduction of oceanic lithosphere to the south-east, beneath the Welsh mainland, and assumed that all of the components represented part of one contemporaneous subduction system. Radiometric data available at this time were largely Rb-Sr and K-Ar age dates of uncertain reliability and with relatively large analytical errors, which did not allow the age relationship of the different elements to be confirmed. Subsequently the application of the more precise and robustly interpretable U-Pb zircon and Ar–Ar mineral techniques has enabled the sequence of events in the history of this destructive margin association to be recognized, as summarized earlier in this chapter and detailed in
The early models paid little or no attention to the possibility of transcurrent displacements. Subsequent work (Gibbons, 1983, 1987, 1990) has shown this mechanism to be of great importance, to the extent that it is no longer possible to assume that the juxtaposed terranes (and the diagnostic units identified above) always had the same spatial relationship in the past. Neither is it certain that the distinctive Monian Composite Terrane was part of the same arc-trench system as the British type-Avalonian terranes, as suggested by Gibbons and Horák (1996). The following synthesis is therefore presented in the light of the caveats identified above.
- The oldest suites recognized (Stanner–Hanter, Malverns, Johnston complexes) are associated with an early phase, from 700—?640 Ma, of subduction-related calc-alkaline arc magmatism within the Cymru and Wrekin Terranes
(Figure 1.4) . The pre-existing continental crust in these terranes is nowhere exposed, but isotopic evidence suggests that it may be as old as mid-Proterozoic (Tucker and Pharaoh, 1991). Pervasive metamorphism, ductile deformation, uplifi and erosion followed crystallization of plutonic suites at moderate crustal depths. This was followed after a considerable period of time by the 'Main Magmatic Event' of Gibbons and Horák (1996), during which several subduction-related calc-alkaline magmatic suites (Padarn, Sarn, Charnian, Glinton) were erupted or emplaced in the Cymru, Charnwood and Fenland terranes between 620 and 585 Ma. - Rifting of some of these arc terranes, particularly the Wrekin Terrane, is reflected in the late (570–560 Ma) eruption of transtensional and marginal basin volcanic suites (Uriconian, Coomb, Warren House), but as it is unclear to which arc they lie marginal with, the polarity of subduction is equally uncertain. If the arc was the same as that forming the source of the Pebidian lavas, in the Cymru Terrane, then subduction may have been toward the southeast as proposed in the early models, although with an increased oblique component of convergence
(Figure 1.4) . - Voluminous sedimentation in rapidly subsiding transtensional pull-apart basins (Longmyndian, upper Arfon Group) reflects either the increasingly oblique nature of convergence and/or the onset of terrane dispersal (Gibbons and Horák, 1996), as shown in
(Figure 1.4) . - Subsequent inversion of these basins was accompanied by deformation resulting in recumbent folding, mild metamorphism and weak cleavage formation (BGS, work in progress). Unlike the Cadomian terranes of Armorica (northern France), there is an apparent lack of intense cleavage development and syntectonic plutonism, although this may simply reflect a different level of erosion.
The implications of the above sequence of events are that the amalgamation of the Avalonian terranes, at least in southern Britain, was a rather long-lived and progressive affair.
Gibbons and Horák (1996) have suggested that the Coedana Complex may be interpreted as a frontal arc sliver generated, during late oblique convergence, from the same destructive margin as the British Avalonian terranes. The similar age of the main calc-alkaline plutonic phase in Anglesey (Coedana Granite) to the Main Magmatic Event in the British Avalonian terranes is compatible with this idea. The blueschists and Monian Supergroup can then be interpreted as fragments of an accretionary prism caught between slivers of dismembered arc (e.g. Bwlch Gwyn Tuff on Anglesey and Padarn Tuff of the Arfon Group) and fore-arc (Central Anglesey Gneiss) crust. Hence the overall polarity of this system, with more primitive oceanic components to the north-west, would be in agreement with SE-directed subduction polarity proposed in the early published models.
The Precambrian events described above had by mid-Cambrian time (at the latest) produced a somewhat heterogeneous amalgamation of disparate terranes at the margin of Gondwana. In early Ordovician time part of this recently accreted crust was rifted away, producing a new terrane, known as Avalonia' (Ziegler, 1982), of which the crust of southern Britain occupies the eastern part. Benchmarks in the history of this new terrane and its subsequent accretion into the Caledonian Orogen are documented in
The GCR Precambrian site networks, and rationale of site selection
In this account the general principles of site selection described in the introductory GCR volume (Ellis et al., 1996) are adapted to the complex problem of assembling the Precambrian sites into what is hoped will be an easily understandable and usable descriptive framework. It has been seen that the outcrops within the Precambrian GCR Block in England and Wales are strongly controlled by the reactivation of ancient crustal lineaments, the most important dividing the Precambrian into crustal domains that are geological 'terranes' (see above for definition and explanation of this term). In this volume therefore, each terrane forms the basis for an individual GCR site network, composed of a cluster of sites that are generally in close proximity to each other. The relationship between the Precambrian GCR Block, its various terrane-dependent networks and the sites within each network is portrayed diagrammatically in
I The site includes features of international geological importance (for example, all of the palaeontological sites are given this category).
R The site includes features of national importance because they are representative of an Earth science event or process fundamental to Britain's Earth history, or the history of evolution of a particular GCR network.
E The site includes exceptional features that are scientifically important.
These components are not mutually exclusive, but for convenience, the highest of these components takes precedence in
For the detailed site descriptions that follow, each network of sites is usually allocated a single chapter, but to take account of user convenience some of the chapters are geographically based. For example, Chapters 2 and 3 represent sites within a single terrane (or GCR network) which happen to fall within different regions. Areas occurring between site networks, where the Precambrian basement is invariably deeply buried by Phanerozoic strata, can yield important information on the nature of the Precambrian rocks from the sparse coverage of deep boreholes shown in