May, V.J. & Hansom, J.D. 2003. Coastal Geomorphology of Great Britain, Geological Conservation Review Series No. 28. JNCC, Peterborough, ISBN 1 86107 4840. The original source material for these web pages has been made available by the JNCC under the Open Government Licence 3.0. Full details in the JNCC Open Data Policy
Carmarthen Bay, Carmarthenshire
V.J. May
Introduction
Carmarthen Bay is formed by the estuaries of the rivers Taf Twyl and Gwendraeth where they enter the sea between the Carboniferous Limestone headland of Worms Head on the Gower Peninsula and Caldey Island (see
- Whiteford Burrows and Rhossili Bay (see
(Figure 11.17) and(Figure 11.18) ) - Cefn Sidan Sands, Tywyn and Pembrey burrows (see
(Figure 11.15) ), and - Pendine Sands and Laugharne Burrows (see
(Figure 11.14) ).
These three units can be further subdivided into 8 subsites (see 'Description' below).
The estuaries of the rivers Tat Twyi and Gwendraeth separate units 2 and 3, whereas units 1 and 2 lie to the south and north of the Loughor estuary respectively. Parts of these estuaries are included in the site.
Both Pendine–Laugharne and Whiteford beaches form spits that trend away from a predominantly rocky cuffed coastline, whereas the barrier beach from Cefn Sidan to Pembrey links to the mainland only by former dunes and reclaimed marshland. This barrier feature is only one of three large barrier systems in England and Wales, the others being Scolt Head Island (North Norfolk Coast) and parts of the Holy Island, Northumberland, site. During the 20th century, the general trend has been for erosion at the proximal end of the spits, accretion at their distal ends and extensions of the forms into the estuaries
Apart from the coasts of north Norfolk and Holy Island, Carmarthen Bay contains the largest assemblage of unmodified sandy beaches in England and Wales, but it has received very limited attention in the literature. North (1929) and Steers (1946a) concentrated mainly upon the hard-rock coastline and the evidence of changes in sea level. Savigear (1952) saw the eastward growth of the Pendine beach as controlling slope development on the abandoned cliffs behind the beach and marsh. Kahn (1968), Potts (1968), Jago (1980) and Jago and Hardisty (1984) described the sediments and the geomorphological processes that act upon individual parts of the site. Barber and Thomas (1989) have considered the whole bay in terms of sediment transport and its effects on the beaches. Emerged ('raised') beaches and periglacial and fluvioglacial deposits occur at several points around the bay and many writers have considered the Quaternary history of the area and Campbell and Bowen (1989) provide a comprehensive summary.
Description
There are eight major subsites, each of which is described in turn from west to east. These sub-sites form parts of an integrated whole that is bounded in the south-east by Worms Head and in the north-west by Ragwen Point. The eight units (for locations see
- Pendine Sands and Laugharne Burrows
- The estuaries of the Taf and lywi
- Cefn Sidan, Tywyn and Pembrey Burrows (including the Gwendraeth estuary)
- The Loughor estuary (uncluding Llanrhidian saltmarsh)
- Whiteford Burrows
- Broughton Bay burrows and cliffs
- Rhossili Bay
- Worms Head and Mewslade Bay
Consideration of processes at other GCR sites led to the decision to treat the whole of Carmarthen Bay as a single unit in the GCR, defined by the low-water limits of the intertidal zone at Ragwen Point and Rhossili. In addition, the cuffed coast around Worms Head, which is an important site in its own right, was integrated with the larger Carmarthen Bay GCR site. The site includes all the intertidal sand banks of the bay and the channels between them. The seaward boundary crosses the channels at their most seaward extent. Because the processes that affect the site extend into deeper water, an appropriate geomorphological boundary lies along a straight line from Ragwen Point to Worms Head.
The site comprises 32 morpho-sedimentological units of which ten are hard-rock cliffs, seven are saltmarsh, six are stable or prograding beaches and three are sandy beaches affected by erosion. The remainder are till cliffs undergoing erosion (one unit), estuary/ria (two units), shingle beach (two units), and pocket beach (one unit). Depending upon tidal and wave conditions, sediments can move between most parts of the site, with the possible exception of the area south of Worms Head
The north-western extremity of the site at Ragwen Point
Pendine Sands and Laugharne Burrows are dominated by dunes up to 700 m wide that extend some 9.5 km to Ginst Point
The 0.5 km-wide Taf estuary is bounded by rock cliffs on its western side, but on its eastern side a cobble spit (Black Scar) narrows the channel, and there has been some development of saltmarsh. Vertical cliffs about 30 m high form the shoreline around Wharley Point
The Gwendraeth estuary is dominated by sandflats and mudflats that merge into a growing saltmarsh in the lee of Tywyn Point
The saltmarshes of the Burry Inlet comprise the most extensive area of saltmarsh in Wales: 2121 ha out of a total of 6712 ha (32%), and represent almost 5% of all British saltmarsh. Those of the south shore of the estuary from Whiteford Point to Loughor are of interest for the range of geomorphological features they display, particularly saltmarsh creeks, saltpans, erosion cliffs and range of sediments
The marshes extend for about 15 km along the northern shore of the Gower Peninsula and are up to 1.5 km wide. Landimore Marsh in the west lies in the shelter of Whiteford Burrows and is the youngest of the marshes. Llanrhidian Marsh is more exposed to waves entering Burry Inlet from the west, but Berthlŵyd Marsh is in the more sheltered upper part of the estuary. The marsh sediments have not been dated. The tidal range at springs is 6.6 m and at neaps 3.7 m (Pye and French, 1993). Fine-grained sediment deposition is restricted to the more sheltered upper intertidal zone and upper reaches of the estuaries. According to Carling (1981), grain size typically becomes finer with increasing elevation, and Pye and French (1993) record the mean grain size on the upper tidal flat as sands, on the marsh edge as sandy silts, and on the upper marsh as clayey silts. The marsh-edge is widely marked by a low cliff formed during periodic storm activity. Gently sloping ramped margins occur in areas of pioneer marsh prograda-tion. There are some weakly developed terraces, the transition being marked by low cliff, ramp or residual mud-mound topography. Many creeks on the upper marshes show infilling in response to a reduction in tidal capacity while the marshes grow both vertically and laterally (Pye and French, 1993), but common cord-grass Spartina anglica was introduced to Loughor in 1931 and colonized rapidly in the 1950s and 1960s, but appears to have declined since (Hubbard and Stebbings, 1967; Burd, 1989). Smith (1978) identified subsurface piping patterns in this area, and attributes the development of saltpans (Packham and Willis, 1997) to their presence. At Landimore, an intricate and deep creek network is present. Small-scale mass-movements in rills and creeks in the muddy intertidal zone play an important role in the changes in creek morphology, the supply of sediment into the creeks, and in intertidal drainage patterns (Allen, 1989).
Whiteford Burrows extends some 3 km northwards from the northern side of the Gower Peninsula to Whiteford Point (
The coast westwards to Burry Holms
Burry Holms, an island at high water, forms the northern end of Rhossili Bay, a c. 450 m-wide smoothly curving sandy beach directly aligned to the prevailing and dominant south-westerly waves
The southern boundary of Rhossili Bay is formed by high limestone cliffs that are continued beyond a gap of 500 m to Worms Head
Interpretation
This old cliffed coastline preserves coastal forms of considerable age that have been retrimmed recently to provide the framework within which the extensive recent sedimentation has formed intertidal banks, beaches and saltmarshes. The interpretation of the coastline of Carmarthen Bay involves both explanation of the form and development of the coast during the Quaternary Period and the forms and processes that are active today.
Carmarthen Bay is an excellent example of a coastline whose outline was moulded by marine and subaerial processes throughout the Quaternary Period, but where the shoreline and its detail is much more recent in origin. Each subunit of the site is distinguished by features of major geomorphological interest. For example, the Loughor estuary saltmarshes form a key area for the understanding of saltmarsh dynamics, sediment transport, and sea-level changes, and the platforms and cliffs in Rhossili Bay are excellent examples of hard-rock erosional forms including features linked to former sea levels.
The Quaternary history of Carmarthen Bay indicates that it was affected by several phases of lower sea levels, glacial and glaciofluvial action, and periglaciation superimposed on a framework of river valleys. The interpretation of a number of cave and other sediments containing emerged beach deposits point to a sea level dose to the present-day level about 200 000 years BP during Oxygen Isotope Stage 7 (Campbell and Bowen, 1989), and another period of emerged beach formation (sometimes referred to as the 'Patella' beach) about 125 000 years BP during the Ipswichian (Oxygen Isotope Substage 5e) in which two emerged beach facies have been identified at the western end of Carmarthen Bay at Gilman Point (Bowen, 1970). Extensive periglacial activity led to head deposits forming during the onset of the Devensian and point to considerable cliff instability on parts of the coast. For example, John (1971, 1973) regards the presence of very large quartzite boulders in the head around Ragwen Point as an indicator of an intensive period of slope instability
Modern processes have served to erode or protect parts of the older shoreline, although there is some doubt as to the extent that protection has lead to significant recent change in the older hard rock slopes. Savigear (1952), for example, argued that as the Pendine beach grew eastwards it protected former rocky cliffs and that the slope profiles demonstrate the effects of progressive protection of the cliff foot on slope proffie. Attractive though this interpretation is, there are some difficulties: the slope profiles are not a simple progression from steep at the distal end to gentle at the proximal end of the spit; they have probably been affected by subaerial processes over a much longer time than the period of the extension of the spit, and more recent interpretations of the Pleistocene history of the area indicate that most change in these slopes occurred during intense periglacial conditions during Devensian times. Basal removal would have begun again with sea levels attaining present-day levels about 6500 years BP and would have then ceased sequentially from west to east. This may have done little more than exhume older cliffs.
The modern shoreline is a very dynamic one, as a result of the growth of spits, dune and salt-marsh development, changes in intertidal and deeper water bathymetry and erosion of both beaches and cliffs.
There are few sites in Britain that have been so little affected by anthropogenic interference and which contain such a fine assemblage of coastal forms. Carmarthen Bay is the only coastal assemblage GCR site that is directly affected by the Atlantic wave systems; it also contains four estuaries. Like the other coastal assemblage GCR sites, it gains its greatest importance from its completeness and the fact that it can be defined as a single unit in terms of its overall sediment dynamics.
It is apparent from the field studies that the individual parts of the site are interconnected with sediment moving between intertidal sands and the beaches, and therefore able to move from one subunit to another. Similarly there is evidence of sand movement from Rhossili Bay to the Whiteford Burrows spit and beyond.
In recent years concern about erosion of parts of the beaches, particularly at Pembrey, led the Coast Protection Authorities responsible for to commission studies of the bay treating it as a single coastal 'cell'. The Carmarthen Bay Study (Barber and Thomas, 1989) shows that the shape of the modern coastline is dominated by the high-energy, south-westerly wave regime interrupted by the discharges of the two major estuaries. Tidal streams in the bay have three dominant effects:
1. On the ebb tide they produce significant refraction of waves,
2. direct scour by currents occurs at the distal end of spits, particularly at Ginst and Tywyn Points, and
3. currents are also important mechanisms for moving sediments stirred up by wave action on the intertidal banks.
Waves are affected by refraction especially over the shallow areas of the estuaries, and by currents. Over the shallow inlets there is some partial breaking of waves, and the effects of bottom friction and shoaling on waves are particularly strong over the wide intertidal areas. As a result there is considerable stirring of sediments that can then be moved by tidal streams. Wind action also plays a major role in the movement of sand between intertidal drying areas and the dunes. This is especially important with dominant and prevailing westerly winds. There are distinct differences in the recent patterns of accretion on the three main beaches
Modelling of wave conditions in Carmarthen Bay (Barber and Thomas, 1989) showed that changes in bathymetry between 1977 and 1988 had significantly changed both the direction and the intensity of wave attack within the Loughor estuary and the joint estuary of the rivers Taf and Tywi. Sediment transport was also affected. According to the model, nearshore wave conditions were critically affected by the direction of approaching waves and the magnitude and direction of tidal streams. For example, during a model SSE storm with significant wave height (Hs) = 2.7 m and wave period (Ts) = 6.3 s), wave attack was concentrated on the central part of Cefn Sidan–Tywyn–Pembrey area two hours before high water. This could account for the observed erosion on this beach and the tendency for transport towards both ends of the beach. However, the most significant feature of both the model and the empirical studies is their definition of the bay as a single sedimentary unit.
Barber and Thomas (1989) argued that the approach of the Carmarthen Bay Study provides a 'modern' tool to aid decision-making regarding development and conservation proposals affecting a specific shoreline and its neighbours within a recognizable coastal 'cell'
Further interest is added by the saltmarsh morphology. The saltmarshes of the Burry Inlet comprise the most extensive area of saltmarsh in Wales, and those of the south shore of the estuary from Whiteford Point to Loughor are of particular interest for the range of geomorphological features that they display, particularly saltmarsh creeks, saltpans, marsh terraces, erosion cliffs and the range of sediments. Understanding of the long-term dynamics of saltmarshes in the Bristol Channel has been focused mainly in the Severn estuary and there has been comparatively less attention given to those of the Burry Inlet. Within the Severn marshes, geomorphological and sedimentological techniques were used by Allen and Rae (1987, 1988) to elucidate the oscillations of late Holocene shorelines and to describe vertical saltmarsh accretion since the Roman period (c. 2000 years BP). Allen (1990a) has, however, voiced caution about relying upon saltmarsh sedimentation rates as a source of estimates of sea-level change especially because reworking of muddy intertidal sediments is an important process (Allen, 1987). Compaction, the intricate patterns of sedimentation, and local changes of elevation can each lead to errors. Postglacial stratigraphy of the Severn estuary indicates a long-term sea-level rise (about 3–4 m during the last 2000 years (Allen and Rae, 1988; Heyworth and Kidson, 1982) upon which are superimposed several periods of still-stand (Kidson and Heyworth, 1976; Allen, 1990a-c, 1991b, 1992). These interpretations probably also apply to the Burry Inlet, but there has been very limited investigation of them and the magnitude of change is thought to have been less in the Burry Inlet. Relative sea level continues to rise in the region: mean sea level at Avonmouth increased by 1.12 ± 0.62 mm a−1 between 1925 and 1980 (Woodworth et al., 1991) and relative sea-level rise in Carmarthen Bay is estimated at between 1 and 2 mm a−1 (Pye and French, 1993).
Conclusions
Carmarthen Bay has perhaps the most varied assemblage of coastal features in the British Isles and is one of the few sites with limited anthro-pogenic disturbance. There are major dunes, sand spits and barrier beaches, both hard-rock and easily eroded cliffs, rias, emerged ('raised') beaches, extensive intertidal sand-flats and some of the most important saltmarshes in England and Wales. Ages of features in the site range from about 245 000 years old to modern, and the site is crossed by the probable limit of the Devensian ice in Britain.
There is no other site in England and Wales that has such well-developed spit and barrier beaches in a macrotidal regime dominated by south-westerly Atlantic wave conditions, and the site can be regarded as a single sedimentary unit. The interest of the site is heightened by the well-documented Quaternary sequences that occur within it at Ragwen Point, Broughton Burrows, Rhossili Bay and Worms Head, since it is possible to relate the modern features to earlier ones. The comprehensive dating that confirms the longevity of many of the features, notably the cliff-platform sequences and some of the cliff-top dunes at the northern end of Rhossili Bay, is rare and of considerable significance to the understanding of glaciomarine margins and their subsequent development.
The saltmarshes of the Burry Inlet are of major regional and national interest for the range of geomorphological features they display, particularly saltmarsh creeks, saltpans, erosion cliffs and range of sediments, in a macrotidal environment.